當第二季開始時，時間只過了10天；觀眾會看到Sutton和她生母Rebecca（Charisma Carpenter）初度見面的情形，以及她們對他人隱瞞真相的理由。Charisma Carpenter在訪談中的原話是“It’s for Emma’s protection…. The less people who know, the better”。前六集的標題是：2×01 The Revengers2×02 Cheat, Play, Love2×03 Advantage Sutton2×04 A Kiss Before Lying2×05 Much Ado About Everything2×06 Catch Her in the Lie